Beefree blog

11 Mystery Sale Emails With Magnificent Design

Beefree team
Beefree team
Dec 6, 2018
11 Mystery Sale Emails With Magnificent Design
11 Mystery Sale Emails With Magnificent Design

We love emails that make us want to tap or click—like on aone-question survey,hamburger menu, or another fun interactive element. Lately, we've spotted a lot of mystery sale emails that invite us to unveil a mystery code, item, or promotion. Have you ever tried designing an email like this? They're a fun spin on the usual promotional message, creating a bit of intrigue and a sense of playfulness. And with the holiday season upon us, mystery emails might be just the creative tactic you need to cut through the noise. Check out these 11 mystery sale emails for inspiration.

Harry's

Subject: New Mystery Item. That’s all we can say.

mystery sale emails

Step one of a successful mystery email? Mention the mystery in the subject line to get readers curious. And then don't give away too much in the email itself. This email from Harry's is super fun and mysterious. Readers will have little idea what the surprise is; the only hint is that it's a product worth at least $5. Want to know what it is? Us, too! Design-wise, Harry's does a great job of using an HTML background color alongside images, so the email is seamlessly deep teal. There's live text, plus a custom bulletproof button, plus a bit of animation with this sweet little GIF:

mystery sale emails

Moo

Subject: Areyou feeling lucky?

mystery sale emails

This email from MOO kind of takes mystery to a whole other level, doesn't it? We aren't sure what revealing our "score" will mean—but there's only one way to find out! We're inspired by how curious this email makes us feel, and how elegantly it's designed. Like Harry's, the message leverages great HTML background colors, plain text, and a compelling CTA (notably placed above the image). Plus, check out the GIF:

mystery sale emails

Loft

Subject: This may come back to haunt you...

mystery sale emails

This Halloween email from Loft succeeds with great copy and a simple animation. (By the way, have you seen our tutorial on how to create stunning all-text emails?) It's all one image, though, so if you build an email like this, we definitely recommend a fallback, alt text, and moving that CTA button into a new module so it can stand on its own as a bulletproof element.

General Assembly

Subject: It’s here: Our Black Friday mystery sale

mystery sale emails

Are you noticing a trend? Mystery emails go hand in hand with animated GIFs, apparently! But we're not complaining. Animation emphasizes the playfulness of these intriguing messages and adds a little delight to our inbox. This one from General Assembly is perfectly designed to fit the season, though we'd recommend the same CTA-related edits for them as we did for Loft.

Grammarly

Subject: LAST CHANCE: This Mystery Sale Ends in 2 Days

mystery sale emails

Here's a beauty of a mystery email from Grammarly. This time, it's part mystery, part reminder email—one in a series of a drip campaign. The message follows a classic inverted pyramid layout, starting with an image (GIF!), then by a few lines of copy, followed by a CTA. It also employs a fixed-width, which just means the background color of the body of the email is white, while the border is light gray. This makes the central part of the email look "boxed."

mystery sale emails

Teavana

Subject: Everyone Loves a Mystery Deal!

mystery sale emails

It's a mystery email without animation! And it's still just as stunning. This email's high quality photography, ample white space, large type, and easy-to-spot CTA buttons make it pleasant to look at. We wonder, though, how having a second module of non-mystery content impacts interaction with the mystery CTA. (A/B test it!)

Tarte

Subject: SURPRISE DEAL INSIDE

mystery sale emails

For this next set of emails, be sure to hold onto your keyboard! There's a lot of spin action. Tarte's mystery sale email—and the two that follow—all include roulette-inspired GIFs. If your mystery promotion varies for recipients—i.e., some folks will get one discount, like 30% off, while others will get another, like 20% or 10%—using a roulette animation is a fun way to make it feel like a game. Of course, the wheel is just symbolic; readers can't actually interact with it. But the effect is still interesting and—hopefully—engaging! And, you can always build an actual interactive roulette wheel on your landing page.

Logitech

Subject: Your Mystery Coupon Expires TODAY – Up to 25% Off

mystery sale emails

Here's another wheel from Logitech! There are great contrasting colors used here, so each part of this email-in-motion is easy to read and fun to look at.

mystery sale emails

Sperry

Subject: FINAL HOURS: Up to 30% off - Mystery Sale

mystery sale emails

And for good measure, here's one last wheel from Sperry—

mystery sale emails

Dizzy yet?

Lucky Brand

Subject: Our Mystery sale is back for ONE MORE DAY!

mystery sale emails

We love this GIF from Lucky Brand, though it is essentially a single-image email (not a design best practice). But the copy before and after the animation—along with the CTA—could easily be designed in-email instead of baked into an image (especially easy using BEE!)

MAC

Subject: LAST CHANCE to Get a Haute Mystery Haul for Only $49 ($95.50+ value)

mystery sale emails

One last email to round us out! Here's a black-and-white mystery message from MAC, with this animation:

mystery sale emails

There are tons of ways to design your mystery sale email, and we hope these examples leave you feeling inspired! Don't forget to check out afree trial of BEE Proto design magnificent emails with our easy-to-use, drag-and-drop editor. We even have a template for a mystery email right here. You'll also get access to holiday templates, stock photography from Unsplash, and cutting-edge features like background images—No coding required! So get designing, and have fun!

Related posts

Send Error-Free Emails with Confidence Using Beefree

Learn about the Beefree features that can help you and your team catch mistakes, streamline collaboration, and send with confidence every time.
Beefree team
Apr 15, 2025

Using Beefree with Marketo Engage 101

Learn how integrating Beefree with Marketo Engage can help you build high-converting, on-brand email campaigns— faster.
Luca Penati
Apr 4, 2025

What Are Email Security Gateways? A Guide to Secure Communications

Are your newsletters being marked as spam? Discover all you need to know about email security gateways and how to create emails that pass all the checks.
Beefree team
Mar 12, 2025

Send Error-Free Emails with Confidence Using Beefree

Learn about the Beefree features that can help you and your team catch mistakes, streamline collaboration, and send with confidence every time.
Beefree team
Beefree team
15 Apr
2025

We’ve all been there: You craft the perfect email, hit “send”, and just as you settle into the satisfaction of a job well done, someone slacks you: “Hey, something doesn’t look right with that campaign.” 

If this sounds familiar, you should know that you’re not alone: According to the 2025 Really Good Email Survey “90% of email marketers say they have a history of noticing mistakes in their emails after they’ve hit the send button.

This becomes especially common when your team constantly juggles multiple campaigns or makes edits until the last minute. Sadly, even the smallest mistakes don’t just slip through the cracks; they cost you.

Luckily for us all, mistakes can be avoided. And no, not by lighting a Pre-Send Protection Candles™ and hoping for the best. But rather by equipping your team with the right tools that work with your team – not slow them down. Let’s talk about it!

Building your team’s safety net for mistake-free emails with Beefree 

When everyone involved in the email creation process is aligned and supported by smart systems, executing mistake-free emails becomes second nature. Instead of scrambling to do damage control, you’ll want to set up the tools and processes that help your team focus on what they do best: creating emails that connect, convert, and confidently represent the brand.

In this article, we’ll discuss how you can use Beefree to: 

  • Reduce human errors 
  • Implement systems of checks and balances 
  • Establish guardrails & frameworks for on-brand email design

1. Catch mistakes before they happen with Smart Check

Missing links that lead nowhere? Forgotten subject lines? HTML emails that get clipped in Gmail? It’s easy to make little mistakes that derail your campaign’s performance. 

Learn more about Smart Check → 

Beefree’s Smart Check automatically checks your designs and alerts you of any red flags so you can fix them before they cost you opens, clicks, or conversions. Think of Smart Check as your built-in QA partner who will catch:

  • Missing links
  • Heavy images that could slow down email load times
  • Missing subjects & preheaders that impact engagement
  • Missing alt text on images that hurt your email’s accessibility
  • Large HTML files that might affect deliverability (or get clipped in Gmail)

2. Keep every email on-brand with built-in guardrails 

Most of us don’t nail the perfect campaign on the first try. Great emails are a team effort. However, when multiple teams are involved in the email creation process, branding can quickly go off the rails. 

A misused font, clashing colors, or buttons that are too small to click don’t just make emails look disjointed—they can damage your brand’s credibility.

With Beefree’s Advanced Style Kit, you can set clear, predefined guidelines for fonts, colors, spacing, and more—so every design starts on the right foot. Once configured, all new emails automatically inherit your brand styles, reducing the need for constant oversight and minimizing errors.

Advanced user permissions let you lock down specific design elements, giving you full control over what can (and can’t) be edited. That means anyone on your team—regardless of design expertise—can confidently create emails that look and feel like your brand.

3. Empower your team to create with confidence with reusable content

When your team isn’t bogged down by the cumbersome process of creating content from scratch (or fear of going off-brand), they can move faster—and with far more confidence.

With Saved and Synced Rows, you can provide your team with pre-approved content blocks—like headers, footers, and other commonly used design elements—that they can use in their designs without creating them from scratch. That ensures design consistency, eliminates redundant work, and makes email creation a lot faster.

Learn more about Saved Rows → 

4. Ensure your team is aligned with centralized reviews and approvals:

Creating the perfect email often takes a team of designers, copywriters, marketers, and other team members working together. But when multiple people are involved, endless back-and-forth and feedback scattered across multiple conversations and channels can slow things down, lead to miscommunication, and ultimately cause mistakes. 

With Beefree’s built-in commenting, your team can collaborate and share feedback where the work is actually happening—right inside the builder. And if you’d like to involve external reviewers into the review process, you can do that as well. 

Learn more about commenting → 

Plus, with Beefree’s built-in Approval flow, you can ensure your designs are reviewed and approved by the right stakeholders. Stay aligned with real-time notifications on design changes, lock edits on approved content, and get a clear view of project status for smoother team collaboration and high-quality results.

Learn more about Approvals →

5. Need an additional pair of eyes? Use the power of AI to support your team

Take some weight off your team's shoulders and use AI to support them in the final stretch. Whether it’s catching typos, flagging inconsistencies, or suggesting optimization, AI can be a saving grace when deadlines are creeping in.

For those times when you can’t remember the difference between “there, their, and they’re,  Beefree’s  AI Writing Assistant is there to help. This eager-to-learn helper can  review your copy for grammatical errors, tone of voice, and even share suggestions for making it just a bit more compelling. Our AI Writing Assistant can also seamlessly translate content or automatically generate ALT text for images to enhance the accessibility of your emails. 

Learn more about AI-powered content creation in Beefree →

The tangible cost of email mistakes

Mistakes don’t just impact performance; they slowly erode credibility. What starts as a small oversight can be a massive inconvenience for your readers, sending them straight to the unsubscribe button. As for your team, mistakes chip away at their confidence. Instead of brainstorming for the next campaign, they’re scrambling trying to figure out how to do damage control.   

When done right, email is a powerful tool for connecting with your audience. But a single mistake can unravel that connection and undermine trust.

  • A missing or broken links can interrupt your subscribers’ journey to conversion, negatively impacting campaign performance.
  • A missing subject lines means your emails won't stand out in the inbox, hurting your open rate
  • An awkward typo might signal a lack of attention to detail
  • An off-brand design can make your brand look disorganized
  • An email that gets clipped in Gmail because it’s too big means some subscribers might never see the full email content.

Design error-free emails and send with confidence with Beefree 

Beefree helps teams of all sizes create polished, on-brand emails—without the risk of costly errors. With built-in safeguards, streamlined approval flows, and collaboration tools that keep everyone aligned, Beefree acts as your team’s system of checks and balances. From first draft to final sign-off, you’ll have everything you need to send with confidence, build trust, and get results.

Try Beefree's Business for free for 15 days and get access to all of Beefree’s tools that help you catch mistakes, streamline collaboration, and send with confidence every time. Or schedule a call with one of our experts to discover everything Beefree can support your team.

Using Beefree with Marketo Engage 101

Learn how integrating Beefree with Marketo Engage can help you build high-converting, on-brand email campaigns— faster.
Luca Penati
Luca Penati
4 Apr
2025

Marketo Engage is a powerful tool for marketing automation, but when it comes to email design flexibility, many users find its built-in editor limiting. Creating visually compelling, mobile-responsive emails often requires custom coding or workarounds, slowing down workflow and making it harder to execute high-quality campaigns efficiently.

That is where Beefree comes in. By integrating Beefree’s no-code, drag-and-drop email design platform with Marketo Engage’s advanced automation capabilities, teams can build professional, responsive emails without coding headaches and push them directly to Marketo in just a few clicks.

This article explores:

  • The challenges of designing emails directly in Marketo
  • How Beefree solves these pain points
  • A step-by-step guide to integrating Beefree with Marketo Engage
  • Common FAQs and troubleshooting tips

The challenges of designing emails directly in Marketo

Marketo’s built-in email editor is useful for basic templates but presents several limitations for marketers and designers.

  • Limited design flexibility – Customizing layouts, fonts, or interactive elements can be difficult without custom HTML or Marketo’s proprietary syntax.
  • Technical barriers – Advanced customizations often require HTML knowledge or an understanding of Marketo’s email template language, which may not be ideal for non-technical teams.
  • Time-consuming manual processes – Without a centralized style kit, teams may struggle to stay on-brand and often have to manually recreate headers, footers, and other reusable content blocks for each email, adding extra steps and slowing down production.

Due to these challenges, many marketing teams turn to external email builders like Beefree, FeedOtter, or Knak to improve design efficiency and automation.

(source)

Why Beefree is the best email builder for Marketo Engage

While other external email builders like Knak and FeedOtter also integrate with Marketo, Beefree offers distinct advantages.

  • No-code drag-and-drop builder – Enables teams to design professional emails without writing any code.
  • Advanced design features – Provides more customization options beyond what Marketo’s built-in editor allows.
  • Mobile-responsive templates – Ensures emails adjust automatically for both desktop and mobile devices.
  • One-click export to Marketo – Simplifies the process of moving email designs directly into Marketo Engage.
  • Ability to update existing templates – Allows quick updates without requiring manual re-imports of HTML files.
  • Team collaboration – Enables teams to work together in real time, with built-in guardrails and approval controls to ensure error-free emails before exporting.

By integrating Beefree with Marketo, marketing teams eliminate design frustrations and manual email imports, allowing them to focus on high-performing email campaigns.

Learn more about Beefree's integration with Marketo Enagage [https://support.beefree.io/hc/en-us/articles/24837761625618-Export-Emails-to-Marketo]

(source)

How to update existing email templates in Marketo

Instead of manually editing HTML, Beefree allows users to edit emails in Beefree and update existing ones in Marketo Engage with one click.

  1. Open the email design in Beefree.
  2. Make changes and click “Export.”
  3. Select “Update Existing” to overwrite the previous version in Marketo Engage.

This feature ensures that emails and templates remain up to date without requiring complex HTML edits or duplicates.

(source)

Frequently asked questions on using Beefree with Marketo Engage

Can I use Beefree with other ESPs besides Marketo Engage?

Yes! You can connect Beefree to any ESP, MAP, or CRM including Mailchimp, HubSpot, Salesforce Marketing Cloud, and others. To learn more about how to integrate Beefree to your sending platform watch the video below: 

For a full list of our native integrations visit [https://beefree.io/integrations].

Are there any limitations when exporting Beefree emails to Marketo?

Yes, there are a few important limitations to be aware of:

  • Charset emojis are not supported in Marketo. Including emojis in your email content may result in an error. To prevent this, Beefree automatically replaces unsupported emojis with a placeholder. For more details, refer to the [Marketo documentation on emoji support].

Preheader text is not a native field in Marketo. However, Beefree includes it by embedding the preheader directly in the email's HTML code during export.

Additional resources and links

Why you should use Beefree with Marketo Engage

By integrating Beefree with Marketo Engage, marketing teams gain a faster, more flexible way to build high-converting, on-brand email campaigns—while leveraging Marketo’s powerful automation and analytics to track performance and optimize results.

  • Design responsive, professional emails with ease.
  • Maintain brand consistency across every message.
  • Collaborate efficiently and gain insights to improve campaign performance.

Ready to elevate your Marketo email marketing? Try Beefree today and streamline your entire email creation process.

Start your 15-day free Business trial today!

(source)

Stay informed on all email trends

From the latest creative design strategies that inspire your next campaign to industry best practices and tech advancements, our newsletter is the go-to for all things creation.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
By clicking Subscribe you're agreeing with our Privacy Policy
Beelo here 👋 Got questions?
1